Competition - First Clue!

Well, it's been two weeks since I started my little guess-the-missing-word-in-the-lyrics competition. Here are the 15 entries so far.

Angela: sarsparilla
Angie: damn, booger, macaroni
Sarah: punk, Jesus, platypus, llama, chocolate, fishlips
EmmaJ: giraffe
Alastair: coffee, time, spatula, turnip

First entry: Angela, with "sarsparilla"
Funniest (to Glenn) entry: Alastair, with "spatula"

HERE IS YOUR FIRST CLUE...
The closest entries to the real answer: Sarah, with "platypus" and "llama", and EmmaJ, with "giraffe".

Keep posting... I'll keep chuckling... and next week there will be another clue.